Universal health care

I’ve recently got into a discussion with my brother on the issue of universal health care. It’s a big debate and one which we may be far from agreeing on. It boiled down to two basic issues – freedom of choice and trust.

My brother doesn’t believe in the welfare state because he doesn’t think the state is better than its population and we shouldn’t depend on it. According to him, the state shouldn’t abandon education and health care but should focus on providing it to those who need it as opposed to those who want it. He was very alarmed when I mentioned there’s no private health care in Canada. He felt that the lack of alternative hurts his individual rights to choose the kind of health care he wants.

In theory, I have nothing against the co-existence of public & private education and health care. In practice, I don’t think it works. Take universal health care for instance. I think it only works when an influential segment of our population, the educated middle class, the opinion-makers, rely on the system and therefore demand a certain basic quality. If you have a private alternative, the minute the first glitch on the public system appears, this influential group moves on the private option, which is easier than demanding change on the public side. Soon all the ones left using the public system are only those who need it – those on the margins of society, who can often be ignored by the policy makers. The pressure to keep the system working well disappears and soon only those with money can receive quality care.

That, to me, limits my freedom of choice as an individual. If my choice of hospital or treatment is limited by the amount of money I have in the bank or the kinds of benefits I get from my employer, it hurts my individual rights much more than not having the choice to pay for private health care. Full individual freedom is illusory. Our freedom ends when it interferes with the freedom of our neighbour. We all have the right to quality health care irrespective of our previous health history, job, class, or financial conditions. If to have that I need to wait a bit more for a non-urgent test because someone else who has a life-threatening condition needs to be taken care of first, I’m happy to oblige. I don’t want to be able to do whatever medical test I want the next day just because I have enough money to pay a private clinic when there are other people who are denied that choice. That, to me, is no freedom.

Update: Interesting article debunking some commonly-held myths about the Canadian healthcare system

Part 2 of article here.

Author: guerson

Food-obsessed historian and knitter.

6 thoughts on “Universal health care”

  1. Hi, Alexandra!

    I just got to know your blog thru the interview you gave to Mirella. It seems I’ll be coming back!!!

    I really liked the discussion you transcripted. Living in Canada and seeing the system of universal health care working gives you the background to support your opinion. Seeing how things occur in Brazil makes it hard to believe we can migrate to that one day.

    I believe we have to change a whole lot of other problems before being capable of providing public care for all!

    Congrats for the blog!

  2. Jeanne
    Pra mim tá parecendo normal… continua ruim pra vc? De vez em quando acontece…


    Welcome to building bridges! The blog is a hodgepodge of different subjects and I hope you find things you like… where do you live?

  3. Alexandra,

    como você escreveu o texto em inglês, acabei respondendo na mesma língua!!! Sou de Sampa, mas como você viu lá no blog, estou passando o ano estudando/estagiando na Europa!


  4. Alexandra,

    mas será que o seu irmão não pensa assim porque no Brasil o cidadão que depender apenas do sistema de saúde público está perdido?

    Bjs bjs

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: