Barcelona is NOT a war zone

In about two weeks, Alan and I will be going back to Barcelona for a month. Of course, for us, visiting Barcelona is not quite living any other foreign destination – we lived there and Alan still fondly refers to it as “home”. But still, I like roaming through travel forums to read about other people’s recent trips, what they saw, what they did. Inevitably, they share their impressions and these can be either positive or negative. While I enjoy reading about other people’s experiences, I also get very frustrated with human beings’ (natural?) propensity to generalize, essentialize, and misunderstand a culture not their own. We have all heard of Parisian waiters’ fame for being surly and rude, which is nothing but a stereotype. In forums about Barcelona, people tend to focus on two issues: crime in Barcelona and the rudeness of the Catalan people.  Because I got tired of trying to dispel some of these notions, or at least to put them in perspective, in the sites I belong to, I decided it was about time I got it out of my system here.

Crime in Barcelona – Sites like Tripadvisor have pages upon pages about pickpocketing in Barcelona. Since places frequented by thousands of tourists daily tend to draw lots of pickpockets, I’d have thought this is more or less expected. But no, unlike those who have been pickpocketed in Paris or London, those who have lost valuable in Barcelona to petty theft of this sort express the same horror as those who have been to war-torn cities. The tone is so alarmist that I, someone who has navigated Rio de Janeiro’s far superior crime rate with ease, arrived in Barcelona two years ago literally anxious and expecting thugs to be hiding at every corner, ready to jump on me as soon as I turned the corner. That is not a nice feeling to have and I soon discovered it was unfounded. Sure, there is a lot of pickpocketing in the most touristy parts of the city (Barceloneta, Barri Gotic, Sagrada Familia & Park Güel) but as long as you take normal precautions that you should take in any big, populous urban area, you are fine. Alan and I walked everywhere, always took public transit, carried around expensive cameras, and never had a problem. We had visitors almost every month we were there, told them to be careful with their stuff, and they never had a problem either. I’m not saying it doesn’t happen and I’m not defending Barcelona just because I like it either, but as a woman who is aware of my surroundings at all times (what I call my Brazilian survival skills), I never felt unsafe in Barcelona. Sure, there are some unsavoury streets in the Raval that made me feel unconfortable but what city doesn’t have a few of those? Besides, while pickpocketing might be a problem (which I have yet to be convinced is any worse than in Rome or Paris), violent crime in Barcelona is very low. I read the newspapers daily and I don’t think I ever heard of a tourist being robbed at gunpoint or a similar incident. But I guess the shock and the indignation of many tourists come from the obvious cultural shock of leaving suburban America or small-town Britain to navigating the streets of a large and crowded urban centre. Many thrive but just as many are quite intimidated by it all.

The Catalans – Where do I start? Maybe it is too Pollyanish on my part, but I don’t believe there is such a thing as a rude people. Visiting a foreign country or city is like visiting someone’s home. You should acknowledge your host, compliment his house, show appreciation for what he offers you, and remember that he doesn’t have to put up with you. Unfortunately, many tourists these days approach traveling like they approach visiting an amusement park – as consumers paying for entertainment. As such, they believe the staff at the amusement park should be happy to comply with their demands and make every effort to make sure they enjoy their time there. (Un)fortunately, places like Barcelona, Madrid, Paris, London or Rome, are bustling cities where people live, work, and go about their daily chores. They are definitely not there just to provide entertainment for tourists.

An additional issue is that many people bring with them preconceived ideas about what the locals are supposed to be like. This is particularly problematic for Spain, a country forcefully carved out of very distinct states/kingdoms with their own cultures, languages, and way of life. Of course there are common elements across the Iberian peninsula, but I’d say it would be as foolish to expect a Catalan to be exactly like a Castilian as it would be to imagine that a Portuguese person is the same as a Spanish. They are definitely not Flamenco-dancing, ole-yelling bullfighters. I think they are a bit more reserved than Castilians, but not at all unapproachable. If you show some remote interest and appreciation for their language and culture, they’ll open up and be very friendly. This is were a bit of cultural sensitivity would go a long way.

We lived in a non-touristy neighbourhood of Barcelona and joined a local gym frequented mostly by Catalans. Neither Alan nor myself have anything bad to say about the people from the gym. Everyone from the manager, to the swim coach, to the personal-trainers, to the instructors, were nothing but nice and welcoming. Had Alan wanted to, he could have been part of their master swim team (the coach invited him numerous times). And both at the bakery near the gym and at the bar near our home, after our first two weeks. we no longer needed to order coffee – it was brought to us, the way we wanted, every time.

Every time I hear someone saying things like “the Catalan are so unfriendly”, I think of our friends Pau & Mireia who picked us up at the train station in their hometown of Vic many times, took us around, introduced us to friends & family and shared with us the best their region had to offer. Or I think of all the staff and security personnel at the archives were I worked, who would invite me for coffee and discuss everything from yesterday’s soccer game to their vacation plans and the state of the economy. Or about my friend Toni, who lives in Salzburg and whom I met on the blogosphere and after knowing I’d be in Barcelona for a few days over Christmas quickly invited Alan and I for a coffee in one of the city’s traditional cafés so that we could finally meet personally. Alan and I felt very honoured by the wonderful gift they brought us from Austria. I could go on and on. My basic point is: there are nice people and rude people everywhere in the world. But it is not their nationality that makes them so. And to label a whole nationality as something is a bit unfair in my books.

Sorry for the long, disjointed rant. I just had to say that. The short version is: Barcelona is not a war zone and the Catalans are not the new French. But do clean your feet before coming in and say hello to the host.

Author: guerson

Food-obsessed historian and knitter.

6 thoughts on “Barcelona is NOT a war zone”

  1. During the month I was in Barcelona, I’ve never felt so safe in my life. In Brazil you can’t walk around with your camera, cell phone, watch, money as loose as you can in there. Just like you said, once you take the basic precautions, it’s a very very safe city. Although I witnessed a robbery at the Swatch store in Passeig de Gracia – and I’m pretty sure the robber was a brazillian :(.
    As for the Catalans, they are very friendly people, if you treat them right. I also have my dearest memories of Pau & Mireia, which you introduced me to and welcomed me to their town and home.
    And, finally, Alex & Alan, honorary Catalans, are also great!!

  2. I’ve lived in Barcelona for a while now and I have many friends here (not one Catalan however), and really enjoy the city. I’ve lived in Raval (Carrer Nou de la Rambla) the whole time, so I guess I am quite clued in on some of the social problems here. You are right that violent crime is very very low, however I’m pretty sure Spain has the highest rate of Petty theft in the entire world.. and Barcelona – being the most visited city in Spain, is the main contributor to this statistic. Obviously, it’s the amount of tourism here encourages petty theft.. and wealthy tourists at that. Unless you are careful here, chances are you will get robbed. The hotspots for pickpocketing and mugging are from Plaza Catalunya seaward.. La Rambla being the worst. And as you say, at the other touristy areas – Parc Guell etc. Anyway, I would disagree with you… I really think that there are huge issues with petty theft in Barcelona, and the authorities utterly fail to tackle the problem. I definitely feel safe in Barcelona (most of the time), but you can’t just sweep the stats under the carpet because you have a couple of Catalan pals.. there is a problem.

    Secondly, I genuinely believe that Catalan people are amongst the rudest, snooty and intolerant people in Europe. It’s not a tiny minority, it’s a sizeable group of wankers. There are a lot of wankers in this city, who seem to ‘hiss’ and ‘psst’ at you when they want your attention. They seem to think that anyone who is not Catalan is a Dog. I also hate how big a deal language is in this city.. and I have been treated like a second-class citizen for not speaking Catalan.. sorry to ‘bore’ you with that complaint, but it’s the bloody truth! Don’t get me wrong, I love this city, however a large amount of locals make it quite difficult. All of the people I know over here have noticed the unfriendly nature of the Catalans, and we all do believe that there are way more wankers here than there are in other large European cities.. I’m just being honest.

    Despite this, Barcelona seems to attract a lot of really interesting people from all over the world, which is great because I won’t be alone with the Catalans.

  3. Pigeon,

    Like I said in the post, pickpocketing IS a problem in Barcelona. And you are right in suggesting the authorities need to do more; I’ve heard that part of the problem is that the law condones theft below 300 euros – if you steal under that amount, it is not considered a crime. What I was reacting against is the way this is talked about – if you read the tripadvisor posts, you’d think Barcelona is a war zone, which, as you said, is definitely not the case.

    As for language and the Catalans we will have to disagree – I think you find that language is an issue no matter where you live. People do tend to prefer to speak their own language in their own country (and I don’t mean country here as synonymous with state obviously). To think less of the Catalans for looking down on you for not speaking Catalan, is like holding a grudge against the French for looking down on you if you didn’t speak French but lived in Paris. I went to Barcelona for a limited time – I knew I was only going to be there for one year – and I didn’t speak Catalan (although I understand it well enough) but I made an effort to at least say half a dozen things and seem apologetic for not speaking the language doing so. It did the trick even in the very Catalan neighbourhood in which I lived. I found the Catalan more reserved – much like the Portuguese – when you first meet them but after seeing the same person 2-3 times, they opened up quite a bit. And once you become friends, they go out of their way for you. It actually made me interested in living in Girona and wanting to learn Catalan. Some of our favourite trips where in fact to the small towns of Catalunya where we never felt unwelcomed.

    As for anti-foreign attitudes, I think you’ll find that in most touristy cities; particularly those that became popular quickly. We need to put ourselves in their shoes sometimes. How would you feel if you were born and raised in a city where you never saw too many foreigners and then suddenly, your city is discovered and thousands of tourists come to visit every year. That in itself is fine but what if some of those tourists also take the attitude that they can do in our city all the things that they feel they can’t do at home like party loudly, get drunk and rowdy, and throw garbage everywhere. Although only a small minority of tourists do that, I wouldn’t be surprised if some locals saw all of us foreigners that way. So if a stranger hisses at me on the street, I don’t tend to think much of it; I understand what they are reacting against. It’s up to me to try to correct that bad impression by showing them that I’m not one of those ugly tourists.

    If you love Barcelona so much, consider that part of what made this city so great is precisely the fact that it is a very Catalan city. I would encourage you to take advantage of the free Catalan courses made available; it is indeed difficult not to feel like a second-class citizen if you don’t speak the local language. You will find that any effort you make in that respect will pay handsomely and you’ll enjoy the place even more.


  4. PS: consider also that you can’t really understand a people if you don’t have a good understanding of their history, language, and don’t have friends among their people (i.e. know someone well enough to be invited to their homes or to meet their families). You admit you don’t have a single Catalan friend. Consider then that a lot of your conclusions about them may be based on cultural misunderstandings…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: